US State School Discipline

Intersectionality is a term that when used in feminism explains how issues that women face, are often seen from a white middle-class narrative. The middle-class feminist narrative, however, does not consider additional factors that can impact a woman’s positionality and experiences, such as disability status, race and Social Economic Status (SES) (Crenshaw, 1991). Intersectionality when used in a feminist context, shows the multiple factors that women of colour, disabled, trans and low SES women face with identity politics and how this can differ greatly from the experiences of a white, middle-class woman and was a focus in third wave feminism, where the different experiences of non-white middle-class women were centralised (Walker, 1992). The need to consider intersectionality when examining feminist issues can be seen by looking at discipline in US state schools and how discipline impacts children from minority backgrounds.

In the US state educational system, African American girls are disproportionately more likely to be disciplined than white girls, this is particularly notable with the introduction of zero tolerance and African American girls being disciplined for minor issues, such as making ‘excessive noise’ or ‘being confrontational’ (NWLC, 2014). African American girls are six times more likely to be disciplined than white girls with 12% of all African American girls excluded from pre-school to grade 12 (NWLC, 2014).

It is argued that children as young as 3 years old are aware of gender and are already conforming to ‘traditional gender stereotypes’ (Skelton et al, 2012), Pane & Rocco (2014) discuss that this directly affects African American girls, as they do not fit into patriarchal middle-class notions of femininity, such as being passive and softly spoken (Arnot & Mac an Ghaill, 2006). These hegemonic stereotypes of femininity and passivity often lead to negative perceptions of African American girls as being loud, disruptive, confrontational and disobedient which leads teachers to feel that they have to correct their behaviour more, in order to bring them in line with their own social values (NWLC, 2014).

This photo shows a child in the 1950s taking part in a psychological experiment in which he is being asked questions such as, which of the two dolls was good, pretty or nice. The experiment showed that children were more likely to attach words such as ugly and bad to the black dolls due to negative perceptions of African Americans.

However, these negative stereotypes of black women can lead to long-term barriers to education as drop-out rates tend to be higher amongst children that are continually disciplined (NSLC, 2014). The School To Prison Pipeline (STPP) theory can further help understand how discipline in education can affect children in the US. The STPP theory centres on how schools are constructed in a way that fails children from low SES and minority backgrounds through the use of widely excepted classroom disciplinary methods (Pane & Rocco, 2014). These methods of discipline include removing children from their classroom, which can impact on their engagement and interest in education (Pane & Rocco, 2014). Thus, children who are repeatedly disciplined at school may eventually drop out and are at an increased risk of entering the juvenile prison system (Pane & Rocco, 2014), with Black and Latinx females up to three times more likely to end up incarcerated than white people (Sentencing project, 2016: p14)

 

Reference List

Arnot, M. & Mac an Ghaill, M., 2006. Spice Girls, Nice Girls, Girlies and Tomboys: Gender discourses, girl’s Cultures and Femininities in the Primary Classroom. In: The Routledge Falmer reader in gender and education, New York: Routledge. pp121-130.

Crenshaw, K. (1991). Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence against Women of Color. Stanford Law Review, 43(6), pp1241-1299. doi:10.2307/1229039

Jackson Jr., J. P.(2001). Social Scientists for Social Justice: Making the Case against Segregation. New York: NYU Press. Retrieved March 4, 2019, from Project MUSE database.

National Women’s Law Center (NWLC). (2014). Unlocking Opportunity for African American Girls. A Call to Action for Educational Equity. 1 (1), pp6-46.

Pane, D. & Rocco, T. (2014) The Issue / School-to-Prison Pipeline. In: Transforming the School-to-Prison Pipeline. Educational Futures (Rethinking Theory and Practice), vol 60. SensePublishers, Rotterdam

The Sentencing Project. (2016). Racial and Ethnic Disparity in State Prisons. The Color of Justice. 1 (1), pp1-25.

Skelton, C., Francis, B., & Smulyan, L. (2012). The SAGE Handbook of Gender and Education, SAGE Publications, London. Available from: ProQuest Ebook Central. pp120-134.

Walker, R. (1992). Becoming the Third Wave, US. pp397-401.

 

 

The Person is Political- Working Mothers

The person is political- Working Mothers

 

Me with 3 of my children

‘The person is political’ is a slogan that was used by second-wave feminism to show how the multiple areas of a woman’s private and personal life link to wider patriarchal political and societal structures (Evans & Chamberlain, 2014). This can be demonstrated in my experiences of being a mother, in which I have struggled with negative comments and opinions for choosing to work or study, this normally centres around views that a mother’s place is in the home with her children. However, the problem with this ‘idealistic’ view of how a mother should be, doesn’t allow for women to have an identity outside motherhood and although motherhood is part of my identity, I feel that I should not be limited to this one dimension.

The negative views of working mothers are further reinforced by the way mothers are viewed in the context of a heteronormative patriarchal society, where the nuclear family is endorsed in policy and in the media. The nuclear family which is heavily promoted in media usually centres around two heterosexual parents- a stay at home mum and a father who works to support his family (Page, 2013). The problem with this is that this media view is very much translated into societal perceptions of women, who are seen as solely child-carers and nurturers, whereas men are often able to become parents without losing other elements of their identity.

Even when working mothers are portrayed in media, they are often seen as rushing around, too busy to spend time with their children and ‘neglecting their motherly duties’. This can be seen in a BBC short promotional video called Wonderland which aired over Christmas 2018. It shows a working mother ignore her son’s requests to spend time with him due to work related time constraints.

A screenshot of the BBC’s Wonderland showing the main character (a working mother) at her office desk. Her computer screen which she was working on has started to freeze revealing a photo of her with her son

The video clip then displays a scene in which time freezes and the working mother’s computer screen also freezes to reveal a photo of her and her son. This then enables the mother to spend time with her son. Although, promoted as a heart-warming Christmas advert that shows the importance of spending time together as a family, I viewed this as another way to guilt trip mothers into feeling that they cannot combine parenting with other aspects of life and unlike the scene from this advert many mothers cannot simply freeze time or take a day off.

This is particularly important when considering that around 90% of lone parent families consist of lone mothers, of which a high proportion are in employment (Rabindrakumar, 2018). Yet single-parent families form one of the largest groups of people in poverty in the UK, whose lives are often impacted by patriarchal policies that favour the nuclear family and normative gender roles in society. This shows how the ‘the person is the political’ can be applied to the personal choices that parents make about how to structure work and childcare and how this choice becomes political.

 

 

 

 

References

BBC. (2018). Wonderland. Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j3G0UCk3DFA. Last accessed 14th January 2019.

Evans, E. & Chamberlain, P., (2014). Critical Waves: Exploring Feminist Identity, Discourse and Praxis in Western Feminism. Social Movement Studies, 14(4), pp.1–14.

Page, J. (2013). Will the ‘good’ [working] mother please stand up? Professional and maternal concerns about education, care and love, Gender and Education, 25(5), pp548-563, DOI: 10.1080/09540253.2013.797069

Rabindrakumar. S. (2018). One in four A profile of single parents in the UK. Gingerbread. 1 (1), pp3-13. Available: https://www.gingerbread.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/One-in-four-a-profile-of-single-parents-in-the-UK.compressed.pdf

 

Please sign in first
You are on your way to create a site.